Worcester Polytechnic Institute Electronic Theses and Dissertations Collection

Title page for ETD etd-050105-182456


Document Typethesis
Author NameZhao, Lei
URNetd-050105-182456
TitleBench Scale Apparatus Measurement Uncertainty and Uncertainty Effects on Measurement of Fire Characteristics of Material Systems
DegreeMS
DepartmentFire Protection Engineering
Advisors
  • Nicholas A. Dembsey, Advisor
  • John L. de Ris, Co-Advisor
  • Robert Bill, Co-Advisor
  • Keywords
  • measurement uncertainty
  • composite properties
  • Date of Presentation/Defense2005-04-27
    Availability unrestricted

    Abstract

    Traditional probability and statistics methodologies recommended by ISO and NIST were applied to standardize measurement uncertainty analysis on calorimetry bench scale apparatuses. The analysis was conducted for each component instrument (direct measurement) and each related physics quantity measured indirectly. There were many sources contributing to the ultimate uncertainty, however, initially, we dealt with the intrinsic uncertainty of each measuring instrument and the uncertainty from calibration. All other sources of uncertainty, i.e., drift, data acquisition, data reduction (round off, truncation, and curve smoothing) and personal operation were assumed to be negligible. Results were expressed as an interval having 95% confidence that the ¡°true¡± value would fall within. A Monte Carlo Simulation technique with sampling size of 10000 was conducted to model the experiments. It showed that at least 95% of the modeled experiment results were inside the estimate interval. The consistency validated our analysis method.

    An important characteristic of composite material systems is the ability to ¡°custom design¡± the system to meet performance criteria such as cost, durability, strength and / or reaction to fire. To determine whether a new system is an improvement over previous ones and can meet required performance criteria, sufficiently accurate and precise instruments are needed to measure the system¡¯s material properties in bench scale testing. Commonly used bench scale apparatuses are the cone calorimeter (Cone) and the FMGR fire propagation apparatus (FPA). For this thesis, thermally ¡°thin¡± and ¡°thick¡± specimens of a natural composite, red oak, were tested in the Cone in an air environment and in the FPA in a nitrogen environment. Cone test data of two FRP composite systems from the previous work of Alston are also considered. The material reaction to fire properties were estimated considering both ignition and pyrolysis measurements made via the Cone and FPA. Investigation of the ultimate uncertainty of these material fire properties based on the intrinsic uncertainty of the component instruments (e.g. load cell) as well as the uncertainty introduced via use of a current ignition and pyrolysis model are considered.

    Files
  • LZhao.pdf

  • Browse by Author | Browse by Department | Search all available ETDs

    [WPI] [Library] [Home] [Top]

    Questions? Email etd-questions@wpi.edu
    Maintained by webmaster@wpi.edu