Worcester Polytechnic Institute Electronic Theses and Dissertations Collection

Title page for ETD etd-043008-101530

Document Typethesis
Author NameJohnson, Robert A
Email Address rob at jsengineers.com
TitleA Comparison Between Two-Dimensional and Three-DimensionalAnalysis, A Review of Horizontal Wood Diaphragms and a Case Study of the Structure Located at 89 Shrewsbury Street, Worcester, MA
DepartmentCivil & Environmental Engineering
  • Leonard Albano, Advisor
  • Robert Fitzgerald, Advisor
  • Keywords
  • Three-Dimensional Analysis
  • Date of Presentation/Defense2008-04-28
    Availability unrestricted


    A two-dimensional structural analysis design approach has been the universally accepted method for a small structural engineering design firm. The tools to perform the analysis have been paper and pencil, calculators and more recently personal computers with two-dimensional software. With the introduction of three-dimensional software, a major shift is occurring on how small structural engineering firms approach analysis and design. This thesis research reviews the analysis of an existing building utilizing the standard two-dimensional approach, including horizontal diaphragm-action within wood floors. This study also reviews the research performed on horizontal diaphragms and investigates the use of three-dimensional, finite element modeling (RISA-3D) for the analysis of horizontal diaphragms. It is shown that the three-dimensional model can provide results similar to the two-dimensional hand calculations. However, the thickness of the diaphragm elements has to be significantly modified for flexible diaphragm action. The experience described herein is useful for structural engineer interfacing within three-dimensional CAD systems. The thesis concludes with a discussion on the challenges facing small structural engineering firms, including computer based technologies, engineering expertise to develop contract documents and review shop drawings, and outsourcing of design services.

  • rjohnson.pdf

  • Browse by Author | Browse by Department | Search all available ETDs

    [WPI] [Library] [Home] [Top]

    Questions? Email etd-questions@wpi.edu
    Maintained by webmaster@wpi.edu